The Austrian Criminal Code protects the property of others not only from covert removal or fraudulent inducement, but also from acts carried out through violence against a person or by threatening immediate danger to life or limb. This is reflected in sections 142 and 143 of the Criminal Code. Whilst section 142 sets out the basic offence of robbery, section 143 addresses those constellations of cases in which the legislator prescribes significantly stricter penalties on account of particularly dangerous methods of commission or particularly serious consequences. The focus of robbery is therefore not merely the taking of another person’s property. Rather, it concerns the combination of an attack on property with an attack on the victim’s physical integrity or freedom of will. The statutory definitions of (aggravated) robbery may encompass cases ranging from the violent seizure of a bag in a public street (handbag robbery) to a bank robbery.
The significance of violence or threat as a central criterion of distinction
In cases involving allegations of robbery, the decisive distinction from other offences against property is often underestimated: namely, that the taking of the item is compelled through violence against a person or through threats of immediate danger to life or limb. According to the case law, violence is understood as the application of physical force that is more than merely insignificant and capable of overcoming actual or anticipated resistance. The severity of the prescribed penalties demonstrates that robbery is regarded in Austria as one of the most serious offences against property.
Section 142 of the Austrian Criminal Code – Robbery
The basic offence of robbery is set out in section 142(1) of the Austrian Criminal Code. A person who, by using violence against another person or by threatening immediate danger to life or limb, takes or compels the surrender of another’s movable property with the intention of unlawfully enriching himself or a third party through its appropriation shall be liable to imprisonment for a term of between one and ten years.
This shows that the legislator does not treat robbery as a mere aggravated form of theft, but as an autonomous offence carrying a substantial penalty.
Section 142(2) of the Austrian Criminal Code provides, however, for a privileged form of robbery. A person who commits robbery without the use of significant violence and in relation to an item of low value shall, where the act has resulted only in insignificant consequences and does not constitute aggravated robbery under section 143, be liable to imprisonment for a term of six months to five years. Even this so‑called less serious form of robbery therefore remains a felony, although the prescribed penalty is considerably lower than that for the basic offence.
Of particular practical significance is the question of when the use of force can still be regarded as not amounting to significant violence. According to the case law, significant violence is to be assumed where the offender, in attacking the victim’s person, employs considerable physical force in a vehement manner. Conversely, this means that not every physical impact automatically crosses the threshold into significant violence. In this respect in particular, the legal classification in an individual case often depends on the specific details of the alleged course of events.
Section 143 of the Austrian Criminal Code – Aggravated Robbery
Section 143 of the Austrian Criminal Code governs aggravated robbery. It builds upon robbery under section 142 and increases the applicable penalty where particularly qualifying circumstances are present. Aggravated robbery arises in particular where the offender commits the robbery as a member of a criminal association with the involvement of another member of that association, or where the robbery is carried out through the use of a weapon. In such cases, the statutory penalty is imprisonment for a term of one to fifteen years.
Section 143 of the Austrian Criminal Code also qualifies robbery where the violence used results in particularly serious consequences. If the violence causes serious injury to a person, the applicable penalty ranges from five to fifteen years’ imprisonment. Where the use of violence results in bodily harm with severe permanent consequences, the penalty range increases to ten to tw2nty years. If the use of violence leads to the death of a person, the law provides for a term of imprisonment of ten to twenty years or even life imprisonment. Section 143 thus illustrates particularly clearly that, in the context of robbery, the focus is not on the taking of property but on the escalated danger posed to the victim.
Did the offender use a weapon?
Of central practical importance is also the question of whether a weapon was used. According to the case law, the mere carrying of an object is not sufficient to constitute aggravated robbery under section 143, second alternative. What is decisive is whether the weapon is actually used in the application of violence or in the threat of immediate danger to life or limb, or at least is recognisably kept ready to support such coercive means. Case law likewise establishes that a dummy weapon or the mere pretence of carrying a weapon does not satisfy the qualification under section 143 of the Criminal Code.
Summary
Section 142 of the Austrian Criminal Code – Robbery: A person is criminally liable if, by using violence against another person or by threatening immediate danger to life or limb, they take or compel the surrender of another’s movable property with the intention of unlawfully enriching themselves or a third party. For the basic offence, the statutory penalty ranges from one to ten years’ imprisonment.
Section 142(2) of the Austrian Criminal Code – Less Serious Robbery: Where no significant violence is present, the act concerns an item of low value, has resulted only in insignificant consequences, and does not constitute aggravated robbery under section 143, the penalty range is reduced to six months to five years’ imprisonment.
Section 143 of the Austrian Criminal Code – Aggravated Robbery: Aggravated robbery under section 143(1) is committed where the offence is carried out as a member of a criminal association with the involvement of another member, or where a weapon is used in the course of the robbery. In such cases, the statutory penalty ranges from one to fifteen years’ imprisonment.
Serious consequences of the use of violence: If the violence used in the course of the robbery results in serious injury, severe permanent consequences, or the death of a person, the penalty ranges under section 143(2) of the Criminal Code increase respectively to five to fifteen years, ten to twenty years, or ten to twenty years’ imprisonment or life imprisonment.
Significance of the defence: Whether the specific case involves robbery, less serious robbery, or aggravated robbery regularly depends on a precise legal assessment of the alleged use of violence or threats, the resulting injuries, and any potential use of a weapon. For this reason, early criminal‑law advice aimed at formulating the most advantageous account for the accused is of considerable importance.
Allegations of robbery or aggravated robbery rank among the most serious offences within property‑related criminal law. They are also regularly associated with considerable criminal‑law risks. Whether, in a given case, all the requirements of sections 142 or 143 of the Criminal Code are in fact met, whether the qualifying elements are sufficiently substantiated, and which defence strategy is appropriate can only be assessed reliably on the basis of the specific allegation and the procedural posture. Early criminal‑law advice can be crucial in preventing unnecessary or severe legal disadvantages, including the imposition of lengthy custodial sentences.
Contact us to secure your customized defense strategy
Allegations under sections 142 and 143 of the Criminal Code constitute indictable offences and must not be underestimated. Even in cases of first‑time offending, they frequently involve arrest, pre‑trial detention, and lengthy custodial sentences. Suspects should under no circumstances make hasty or unprepared statements. Our criminal‑law advice can be decisive in preventing unnecessary or severe legal consequences for you or for persons close to you. If you or someone close to you is confronted with such allegations, do not hesitate to contact us.
Contact us